Remember these? Oh how I hated them. I am not a games person.
I think of these puzzles when I edit. Revising a novel is like playing a 3-D version of that puzzle. Move one thing, and the rest shift in the worst direction possible. Makes my brain hurt.
When I decided to rework Unstoppable so that moves like a thriller, I knew I’d have to touch up the characters. Events will change, so their reactions to the events will change. Some scenes will be added, others will disappear.
What I didn’t count on the personalities of the characters fundamentally changing solely because of the new configuration.
As I reworked the first half of the novel, I realized that Zeke and Kelsey couldn’t remain as they are. Zeke was too one-dimensional. He was all bad with a few good deeds that Kelsey mistakenly took as a sign that, as they say in West Side Story, deep down inside there is untapped good. If he’s all bad, there’s no tension. He’ll stay bad. He can’t get any worse. It’s the same thing in the Popeye cartoons. Bluto isn’t gonna change. Neither was the old Zeke.
Zeke needs to be more ambiguous through the first third of the book. Kelsey’s best friend, Shania Bean, only sees Zeke’s bad side. Tyne sees the opportunity of escaping poverty that Zeke represents. I’ve played that up in the revision. I’m forcing Kelsey to choose. She has this thing about being right. But now the way the book reads, what is right?
Kelsey in previous drafts was too wimpy, and that was how I wanted to portray her. She was an innocent naive farm girl confronted with A-Team manipulators: Zeke, and his father, the school superintendent. Of course she made mistakes. But now all the characters are fighting a little harder and Zeke is particularly two-faced, putting a self-grandizing spin on everything. It no longer made sense to Kelsey to be wimpy.
She’s now more assertive, but she’s become a flip-flopper rather than a “meh” person. She wants to give everybody the benefit of the doubt, so she comes to Zeke’s defence. Until he does something really stupid. Then she wants to cut ties with him. Later, Zeke and his father put Kelsey in a situation where she feels like she owes both men. She acquiesces, and we understand why.
The result is that her motivation is easier to understand. That keeps the reader invested more. When I taught high school I worked with very bright but wimpy young ladies. I didn’t run across many naive but assertive young women like Kelsey, though a very few were.
Kelsey’s new personality, while not being as true-to-life, and rare, fits better with the overall mission of the story. The higher stakes and heightened action makes her frustrations more poignant. Or so I hope.
I wanted to save all characterization work until I reworked every scene. But waiting was impossible. I can’t rework the scene structure in the second half without knowing how the characters think and feel in the first half.
***
That leads me back to a statement my editor made about six months ago. She didn’t buy that Kelsey would date such a jerk as Zeke. Now I’ve exacerbated the problem. Kelsey is more aware and on guard against Zeke, though she’s not going to act on rumors and gossip. Around the first quarter of the book, In October, Zeke is caught stealing from the school. Kelsey washes her hands of him. She’s done with him.
But. By late November, I need Kelsey dating him again, even if tenuously and on guard. What would make an assertive, bright, very able young lady do this?
Because I am gender-challenged (I admit it, now more than ever, move over Ernie Hemmingway) I asked this question of three nearby women.
My always patient wife, Wendy. She answered that Kelsey should be one of those people who take things at face value and gives everyone the benefit of the doubt. Okay. I used that, but it prompted me to make Zeke more ambiguous (although all ambiguity about Zeke is removed by the midpoint of the novel. Maybe almost all).
My insightful sister-in-law, Rebecca. She loves thought problems like this. She said Zeke would have to do something that would make Kelsey believe he is good at heart, no matter what other evidence is presented. I’m using that. Here’s the subplot in a nutshell: The book begins with Kelsey’s father in jail for unintentional crop damage. His truck brakes failed and he drove through someone’s field. PA state law says he must serve one year. But after 4 months, Dad is magically freed from prison and his fines have been paid off. Voila.
My amazingly creative hair dresser at Tangles Spa, Megan. She says Zeke must show an interest in what Kelsey’s doing, and slowly ease his way into her life. I used this sparingly but may add more.
My goal is to complete the scene restructuring by the Fourth of July holiday. I’ll report on that, and then jump into what will be a huge mess. I need to adjust some of the characterization, and remove as many characters as I can, so that the book is more of a page turner. How’s that going to work? My books and my editor have ideas. Do you? Email me.


